Before leaving a bicycle outside, a child thinks about what could happen if it is left unlocked and decides where and how to secure it.
CT-014
Considering Consequences
Also known as: Thinking About Consequences · Considering Outcomes
What Does It Mean?
Considering consequences means thinking about what could happen because of a choice before deciding what to do.
See It in Real Life
Before a group changes its plan during an outing, the members consider how the change could affect time, safety, other people, and what they still need to accomplish.
Common Confusion
Considering consequences is not the same as trying to predict the future perfectly. A critical thinker identifies reasonable possible outcomes, uses the information available, and allows those possibilities to influence the decision.
Includes
- Cause and effect
- anticipating likely outcomes
- short-term and long-term effects
- intended and unintended consequences
- risk awareness
Find It in Tandem Tales
Practice together
For Educators
The following activities are designed for classrooms, libraries, clubs, camps, and other groups. Each activity requires children to actively practice considering consequences rather than simply listen to an explanation.
CT-014-E01What Happens Next?
View lesson
- Skill in Action
- Children choose among ordinary actions, predict reasonable consequences, and compare different kinds of outcomes before making a decision.
- Recommended Ages
- 6–12. Increase scenario complexity for older students.
- Group Size
- 10+ children; teams of 3–5.
- Preparation Time
- 15–20 minutes.
- Activity Time
- 30–40 minutes.
- Materials
- Choice Cards (A, B, C); Consequence Cards; category cards labeled Helpful, Harmful, Mixed, and Uncertain; likelihood cards labeled Likely, Possible, and Unlikely; table or floor space for sorting; optional recording sheet; pencils.
- Preparation
- Prepare several age-appropriate everyday scenarios with three reasonable choices. Prepare or print the Choice, Consequence, Category, and Likelihood cards. Each scenario should allow more than one plausible consequence so students must compare rather than simply locate an obvious answer.
Instructions
- Divide the children into teams and give each team one scenario plus the Choice Cards for A, B, and C.
- Have the team place the three Choice Cards across a table or on the floor.
- Students select or write Consequence Cards describing things that could reasonably happen because of each choice, then physically place those cards beneath the matching choice.
- For each consequence, students add a Category Card—Helpful, Harmful, Mixed, or Uncertain—and a Likelihood Card—Likely, Possible, or Unlikely.
- Require team members to explain or challenge at least one placement. A student may move a card after hearing a stronger reason from another student.
- After comparing the completed layouts, the team chooses an action and explains which consequences most influenced its decision.
- Rotate scenarios so teams practice with different kinds of choices.
- Bring the group together and compare a case in which a choice produced both helpful and harmful possible consequences.
Example in Action
Scenario: The class is planning an outdoor reading period. The sky is cloudy, but it is not raining. Choice A is to leave the books outside during lunch, Choice B is to carry them back inside, and Choice C is to place them in a covered outdoor bin.
Student sequence:
- Timmy places Choice A on the table and puts the consequence “We save time because the books are already outside” beneath it. He labels that consequence Helpful and Likely.
- Jane adds “The books could get wet if it rains” beneath Choice A. She labels it Harmful and Possible.
- Carlos places “The books stay protected from changing weather” beneath Choice B and labels it Helpful and Likely. He also adds “We have to carry the books twice” and labels that Mixed and Likely.
- Mia works on Choice C. She places “The books may stay dry without carrying them inside” beneath it, but labels the result Uncertain until the team confirms that the bin is actually weatherproof and approved for use.
- Jordan moves one of the cards after hearing Jane’s reasoning and explains why the new placement makes more sense.
Educator action: The educator asks the students to compare the three physical layouts. The team identifies which consequences are certain, which are merely possible, and which matter most. Students then select a choice and point to the specific cards that influenced their decision.
What this demonstrates: Students physically organize possible consequences, classify them, challenge one another’s reasoning, revise placements when appropriate, and use the resulting comparison to make a decision.
Educator Prompts
- What might happen immediately?
- Could something happen later that is easy to overlook?
- Who else could be affected by this choice?
- Which consequence are you most certain about? Which is only possible?
- Would new information change your choice?
Reflection
Ask children to name one example where their first choice changed after they thought about what might happen next.
Real-World Connection
Connect the activity to choices children make at school, at home, during games, online, and while spending time with friends.
Adaptations
For younger children, use pictures and one immediate consequence per choice. For older groups, require short-term, long-term, intended, and unintended consequences.
What Successful Practice Looks Like
Children identify more than one reasonable outcome, distinguish likely outcomes from guesses, and use those outcomes when explaining a choice.
CT-014-E02The Ripple Effect
View lesson
- Skill in Action
- Children physically model how one decision can create a chain of effects that reaches other people or creates later consequences.
- Recommended Ages
- 7–14. Shorten consequence chains for younger students and add indirect or long-term effects for older students.
- Group Size
- 10+ children; whole group or teams of 5–8.
- Preparation Time
- 10–15 minutes.
- Activity Time
- 25–40 minutes.
- Materials
- Open space; decision cards; optional index cards or sticky notes.
- Preparation
- Choose ordinary decisions appropriate to the group, such as leaving group equipment outside, changing a meeting place without telling everyone, or using all of a shared supply.
Instructions
- Read one decision to the group.
- Choose one child to represent the original decision.
- Ask another child to stand beside that person and state one reasonable thing that could happen because of it.
- Continue the chain, with each new child describing a consequence that could follow from the previous consequence.
- Stop when the chain becomes too speculative. Discuss where evidence-based reasoning ended and guessing began.
- Restart with a different choice that could have been made in the original situation.
- Compare the two consequence chains and decide which choice creates the more manageable result.
Example in Action
Scenario: A student uses the class soccer balls at recess and leaves them on the field instead of returning them to the equipment area.
Student sequence:
- Timmy represents the original decision: “I leave the soccer balls on the field because lunch is starting and I do not want to be late.”
- Jane stands beside him and says, “A ball could still be outside when the next class comes to use it.”
- Carlos adds, “If the next class cannot find the ball, they may lose part of their recess looking for it.”
- Mia adds, “If nobody finds it that day, weather or grounds equipment could damage it.”
- Jordan starts to say, “Then the school will have to cancel soccer forever.” The educator stops the chain and asks whether that consequence is reasonably supported.
Educator action: The class decides Jordan's consequence goes too far because the earlier events do not support it. They restart the chain with the alternative decision: Timmy returns the balls before lunch. Students then build a second chain and compare the two.
What this demonstrates: The physical chain shows that consequences can spread beyond the person making the original choice, while the educator's stop point teaches students not to treat every imaginable result as a reasonable consequence.
Educator Prompts
- Did this consequence happen directly because of the choice, or are we making too many assumptions?
- When did the effects begin reaching other people?
- Which consequence would be easiest to prevent?
- Could one small decision create a much larger problem later?
Reflection
Have the group identify the point in the chain where thinking ahead would have made the greatest difference.
Real-World Connection
Use examples from group projects, classroom routines, sports, family responsibilities, community spaces, and digital communication.
Adaptations
Younger groups can make chains of only two or three steps. Older students can compare direct, indirect, short-term, long-term, and unintended effects.
What Successful Practice Looks Like
Children can explain a plausible cause-and-effect chain without treating every imagined outcome as certain.
CT-014-E03What's Our Plan?
View lesson
- Skill in Action
- Children examine a real outing or shared environment, identify what could reasonably go wrong, and help create a practical plan before the problem occurs.
- Recommended Ages
- 5–14. Adapt the amount of independence and complexity to the children and the organization’s safety rules.
- Group Size
- 10+ children; whole class/group with small-team observation.
- Preparation Time
- 5–15 minutes.
- Activity Time
- 15–30 minutes before or at the destination, plus a brief post-outing review.
- Materials
- No special materials required. Optional planning sheet and venue map.
- Preparation
- Select an actual upcoming field trip, library visit, museum visit, park outing, event, or other group activity. Know the organization’s required safety procedures before involving children in planning.
Instructions
- Tell the group where they are going and ask, “What situations should we have a plan for before we go?”
- Let children identify reasonable possibilities, such as becoming separated, missing a meeting time, not recognizing the supervising adult in a crowd, or needing help.
- For each possibility, ask what could happen if the group had no plan.
- Identify the supervising adults and how children can recognize them.
- Establish the official meeting location or procedure and identify appropriate venue employees or other designated helpers.
- At the location, have children observe recognizable landmarks, information desks, employee identifiers, and the agreed meeting area when permitted by the venue.
- Ask children to restate the plan in their own words: “If ___ happens, what do we do?”
- After the outing, briefly review which parts of the plan were useful and what the group would improve next time.
Example in Action
Scenario: Ms. Rivera's class is going on a field trip to a large science museum. Before leaving school, she asks the students to help review what they will do if someone becomes separated from the group.
Student sequence:
- Timmy says, “I could walk around the museum looking for the class.”
- Jane considers the consequence and says, “But the class might be looking for Timmy while Timmy keeps moving, so they could keep missing each other.”
- Carlos says, “We should know where our meeting place is before we start walking around.”
- Mia points to Ms. Rivera and another chaperone and describes what they are wearing so she can recognize them in a crowd.
- At the museum, Jordan notices the staffed information desk and the employee badges. The class confirms which designated adults or museum employees they should approach if the school's field-trip procedure tells them to seek help.
Educator action: Ms. Rivera asks, “If you cannot see the group, what do you do first?” Students restate the school's approved separation procedure in their own words. She then asks what could happen if a student ignores the plan and begins wandering through the museum.
What this demonstrates: Students connect a real plan to the consequences it is designed to prevent. They practice planning before a problem occurs and can explain why particular actions make a difficult situation easier or harder to manage.
Educator Prompts
- What could make it difficult for us to find one another?
- What would make the problem worse?
- Who is an appropriate person to ask for help here?
- What information would a helper need?
- How does making the plan now change what we would do if something happens?
Reflection
Ask children whether planning ahead guarantees that nothing will go wrong. Reinforce that the purpose is to make better decisions if circumstances change.
Real-World Connection
This activity transfers directly to family outings, stores, amusement parks, museums, airports, sporting events, festivals, and other busy public places.
Adaptations
Follow all school, organization, venue, and guardian safety rules. For younger children, keep the plan concrete and short. Older students can identify secondary consequences and propose backup plans.
What Successful Practice Looks Like
Children can identify reasonable consequences of being unprepared and can explain how a specific plan reduces confusion or risk.
Practice in everyday life
For Parents & Families
These activities are intentionally lighter than classroom lessons. They are designed to fit naturally into everyday family life.
Before We Go
Best For: Young children through teens.
Where to Try It: Before a store visit, festival, amusement park, museum, vacation stop, or other busy outing.
What to Do: Ask your child to help make the family plan. Decide what everyone should do if separated, where appropriate help can be found, and what actions might make the situation easier or harder.
What to Ask: “What could happen if we just keep walking around looking for each other?” “What would make it easier for us to reconnect?”
Why It Helps: Children practice considering consequences before a real problem occurs and learn that planning is something they can initiate, not merely something adults do for them.
Two Choices Ahead
Best For: Elementary age and up.
Where to Try It: At home, in the car, while shopping, or during ordinary family decisions.
What to Do: When there are two reasonable options, ask the child to name what might happen with each before the family decides.
What to Ask: “What happens next if we choose this?” “Who might be affected?” “Is that certain, likely, or just possible?”
Why It Helps: It turns everyday choices into short critical-thinking practice without making the activity feel like a lesson.
After the Choice
Best For: All ages.
Where to Try It: After a game, outing, project, purchase, schedule change, or other family decision.
What to Do: Briefly compare what everyone thought would happen with what actually happened. Focus on learning rather than whether the original prediction was ‘right.’
What to Ask: “What did we expect?” “What actually happened?” “What did we miss?” “Would we make the same choice next time?”
Why It Helps: Children learn that consequences can be evaluated afterward and that good thinkers revise future decisions based on experience.
A future opportunity
Create Your Own
Have another hands-on way for children to practice Considering Consequences? Educators will be able to create a real-world activity using the same format as official Tandem Tales lessons and submit it for consideration. Selected activities may become an Official Tandem Tales Critical-Thinking Lesson.
Lesson submissions are not open yet.
