Skip to content
← Critical-Thinking Skills Library

CT-013

Decision Making

Also known as: Making Decisions · Making Choices · Choosing Between Options

What Does It Mean?

Decision making means comparing choices and using relevant information to decide what to do.

See It in Real Life

Example 1

A child compares two routes to an activity by considering time, distance, and whether an adult has approved the route.

Example 2

A student chooses between project ideas by comparing the assignment requirements, available time, and needed materials.

Common Confusion

Decision making is more than picking what you like first. Some decisions are simple preferences, but critical-thinking decisions require identifying what matters, comparing realistic options, and being able to explain why a choice fits the situation.

Includes

  • Identifying the decision to be made
  • recognizing available options
  • identifying relevant criteria
  • comparing choices
  • weighing evidence, needs, risks, and tradeoffs
  • choosing an option for a reason
  • reviewing the decision when new information appears

Find It in Tandem Tales

Practice together

For Educators

These activities require children to actively practice decision making through real decisions, tests, comparisons, revisions, or problem-solving tasks.

CT-013-E01

Choose With a Reason

Ages 6–12 · 30–40 minutes.View lesson
Link to this lesson
Skill in Action
Children compare several realistic options using stated criteria, make a choice, and explain which information mattered most.
Recommended Ages
6–12
Group Size
10+ children; teams of 3–5.
Preparation Time
15 minutes.
Activity Time
30–40 minutes.
Materials
Choice Cards; Criteria Cards; comparison mat or sheet; pencils.
Preparation
Prepare everyday decisions with three reasonable options. Give each decision two to four criteria so there is no automatic answer based only on preference.

Instructions

  1. Give each team a Decision Card and three Choice Cards.
  2. Students identify the decision they are actually making.
  3. Reveal or distribute the Criteria Cards.
  4. Teams compare every option against each criterion.
  5. Students may remove an option only if they can explain which criterion makes it less suitable.
  6. Teams choose the option they believe fits best and prepare a short reason.
  7. Give one new piece of information and ask whether the decision should stay the same or change.
  8. Teams explain why reasonable groups may sometimes choose differently when criteria are weighted differently.

Example in Action

A class has 25 minutes for an outdoor activity. Choices are a nature walk, a field game, or sidewalk chalk. Criteria are setup time, participation by the whole class, and weather. Timmy prefers the field game. Jane notes that equipment setup takes ten minutes. Carlos prefers chalk because setup is fast, but the educator reveals the pavement is still damp from rain. The team chooses the nature walk and explains how the criteria—not just preference—guided the choice.

Educator action: The educator asks students to explain the reasoning behind their action, connect it to the available information, and identify what should remain or change after seeing the result.

What this demonstrates: Children compare several realistic options using stated criteria, make a choice, and explain which information mattered most.

Educator Prompts

  • What decision are we making?
  • What matters for this decision?
  • How does each option fit the criteria?
  • Which information mattered most?
  • Would new information change your choice?

Reflection

Ask students to describe the difference between a preference and a reasoned decision.

Real-World Connection

Connect the activity to choosing activities, project methods, routes, purchases, schedules, and group plans.

Adaptations

For younger students, use two options and two picture criteria. For older students, include tradeoffs where no option is best on every criterion.

What Successful Practice Looks Like

Students identify relevant criteria, compare more than one option, choose for an explainable reason, and reconsider appropriately when new information changes the situation.

CT-013-E02

Decision Corners

Ages 7–14 · 25–35 minutes.View lesson
Link to this lesson
Skill in Action
Children physically move to represent a choice, hear additional reasoning and information, and may change positions when their evaluation changes.
Recommended Ages
7–14
Group Size
10+ children; whole group with three or four choice areas.
Preparation Time
10–15 minutes.
Activity Time
25–35 minutes.
Materials
Choice signs placed in room corners; scenario cards; optional reason cards.
Preparation
Prepare safe, age-appropriate decisions with several defensible choices. Ensure movement space is safe and accessible; provide a seated/card alternative where needed.

Instructions

  1. Post one Choice sign in each designated area.
  2. Read the scenario and give students quiet thinking time.
  3. Students move to the area representing their initial choice or indicate it with a card.
  4. Ask volunteers from each choice to explain a reason without criticizing other groups.
  5. Reveal one additional fact or constraint.
  6. Students decide privately whether to stay or change choices.
  7. Invite students who changed to explain what information mattered.
  8. Repeat with a new scenario and emphasize that changing a decision because of relevant information is thoughtful, not losing.

Example in Action

Students must choose how to spend the final 20 minutes of a class celebration: outdoor game, group drawing, or trivia. Timmy chooses outdoor game. Jane chooses drawing because everyone can participate. The educator then reveals that a thunderstorm has moved into the area. Timmy changes to trivia. The educator asks him to explain the information that changed the decision rather than treating the switch as inconsistency.

Educator action: The educator asks students to explain the reasoning behind their action, connect it to the available information, and identify what should remain or change after seeing the result.

What this demonstrates: Children physically move to represent a choice, hear additional reasoning and information, and may change positions when their evaluation changes.

Educator Prompts

  • Why did you choose that option?
  • What criterion mattered most to you?
  • What new information could change your mind?
  • Did anyone change for a reason rather than because others moved?
  • Can two choices both be reasonable?

Reflection

Ask students how it felt to change a choice publicly and why critical thinkers should be willing to do so when the situation changes.

Real-World Connection

Relate the activity to plans, teamwork, travel, weather changes, schedules, and everyday choices where new information arrives after an initial decision.

Adaptations

Allow students to hold choice cards instead of moving. For older students, add a tradeoff card after the first round rather than a fact that obviously eliminates one choice.

What Successful Practice Looks Like

Students make independent choices, explain relevant reasons, listen to competing reasons, and change decisions when new information justifies doing so.

CT-013-E03

The Real-World Choice Board

Ages 8–14 · 30–45 minutes.View lesson
Link to this lesson
Skill in Action
Children use real information to make a low-stakes class or group decision, documenting criteria and tradeoffs before voting or agreeing.
Recommended Ages
8–14
Group Size
10+ children; teams of 4–6 plus whole-group decision.
Preparation Time
10–20 minutes.
Activity Time
30–45 minutes.
Materials
Real options for a class/group choice; comparison board; pencils; confirmed information about time, cost, rules, materials, or availability.
Preparation
Select a genuine low-stakes choice the group is permitted to make, such as selecting among approved review games, choosing a display layout, or deciding the order of several activities.

Instructions

  1. Present only the approved options and clarify the final decision the group is allowed to make.
  2. Ask teams to identify criteria that genuinely matter.
  3. Confirm factual information needed for the comparison.
  4. Teams rate or discuss each option against the agreed criteria.
  5. Each team recommends one option and states its strongest reason plus one tradeoff.
  6. Compare recommendations before taking the final vote or reaching agreement.
  7. After the activity occurs, briefly review whether the decision worked as expected.

Example in Action

Ms. Rivera lets the class choose one of three approved review activities for Friday. The class agrees that available time, participation, and required setup matter. Timmy's team prefers a quiz game but notes it requires ten minutes of setup. Jane's team recommends a card-sort activity because setup is faster but admits it involves less movement. After comparing the tradeoffs, the class chooses the card sort because Friday's schedule has only 25 minutes. The educator later asks whether the chosen criteria predicted the experience accurately.

Educator action: The educator asks students to explain the reasoning behind their action, connect it to the available information, and identify what should remain or change after seeing the result.

What this demonstrates: Children use real information to make a low-stakes class or group decision, documenting criteria and tradeoffs before voting or agreeing.

Educator Prompts

  • Which criteria actually matter?
  • Are we comparing confirmed facts or assumptions?
  • What tradeoff comes with your preferred option?
  • What is your strongest reason?
  • Afterward, did the decision work the way we expected?

Reflection

Ask students whether voting first and reasoning afterward would have produced the same quality of decision.

Real-World Connection

Connect the activity to family planning, club choices, project selection, purchases, scheduling, and civic or community decisions where people compare options before choosing.

Adaptations

For younger students, let the educator supply the criteria. For older students, have teams justify why a proposed criterion is relevant before it is added to the board.

What Successful Practice Looks Like

Students define a real decision, use relevant criteria and confirmed information, acknowledge tradeoffs, and make a choice that can be explained and later reviewed.

Return to top ↑

Practice in everyday life

For Parents & Families

These activities are designed for natural everyday practice with an individual child, siblings, or a small family group.

What Matters Most?

Best For: Ages 5+

Where to Try It: When choosing between two or three family options

What to Do: Before choosing, name two things that matter for the decision—such as time, cost, weather, distance, or what everyone needs.

What to Ask: What matters for this choice? Which option fits those things best?

Why It Helps: Children learn that good decisions depend on relevant criteria, not only immediate preference.

Give Me Your Reason

Best For: Ages 5+

Where to Try It: During ordinary choices about games, meals, activities, or plans

What to Do: Let the child choose, but ask for one reason connected to the situation. Accept reasonable differences rather than demanding the adult's preferred answer.

What to Ask: Why does that option make sense here? What is one drawback?

Why It Helps: Children practice explaining decisions instead of treating choices as unexplained impulses.

New Information, New Choice?

Best For: Ages 7+

Where to Try It: When family plans change because of weather, time, availability, or another real condition

What to Do: Return to the original choice and ask whether the new information is important enough to change it.

What to Ask: What changed? Does it matter to our decision? Should we stay with the plan or revise it?

Why It Helps: Children learn that revising a decision in response to relevant information is a strength.

Return to top ↑

Practice Through Games

A future opportunity

Create Your Own

Have another hands-on way for children to practice Decision Making? Educators will be able to create a real-world activity using the same format as Tandem Tales lessons and submit it for consideration. Selected activities may become an Official Tandem Tales Critical-Thinking Lesson.

Lesson submissions are not open yet.