Skip to content
← Critical-Thinking Skills Library

CT-005

Evaluating Information

Also known as: Assessing Information · Judging Information · Evaluating Sources and Claims

What Does It Mean?

Evaluating information means deciding how useful, trustworthy, relevant, or well-supported information is before relying on it.

See It in Real Life

Example 1

A child hears two different explanations for why an event was canceled and checks the official notice before repeating either one.

Example 2

A student compares a dated webpage with a current museum schedule before deciding which hours to use.

Common Confusion

Evaluating information does not mean automatically distrusting everything or deciding whether you personally like the information. It means using reasonable criteria to judge how much the information should be trusted or used for the purpose at hand.

Includes

  • Judging usefulness, accuracy, credibility, relevance, and completeness
  • comparing stronger and weaker information
  • checking sources
  • identifying missing support
  • deciding how much confidence information deserves

Find It in Tandem Tales

Practice together

For Educators

These activities require children to actively practice evaluating information through hands-on decisions, comparisons, investigations, organization, or real-world application.

CT-005-E01

Which Source Would You Use?

Ages 8–14 · 30–40 minutes.View lesson
Link to this lesson
Skill in Action
Children compare several possible sources for the same practical question and decide which source is most appropriate and why.
Recommended Ages
8–14
Group Size
10+ children; teams of 3–5.
Preparation Time
15–20 minutes.
Activity Time
30–40 minutes.
Materials
Question cards; source cards; evaluation mats with Source / Current? / Direct? / Relevant? / Why Use It?; pencils.
Preparation
Create everyday questions with several possible sources. Sources should vary in directness, currency, expertise, and relevance without requiring internet access during the activity.

Instructions

  1. Give each team one practical question and four or five source cards.
  2. Students identify what information the question actually requires.
  3. Teams examine each source using the same criteria: who or what provided it, how current it is, whether it directly addresses the question, and whether important information is missing.
  4. Students rank the sources from strongest to weakest for this particular question.
  5. Teams must explain why their top source is more useful than the others rather than simply naming it.
  6. Give one new fact about a source, such as an old date or direct responsibility for the information, and let teams revise their ranking.
  7. Compare rankings across groups and discuss when more than one source may be useful.
  8. Finish by asking whether the best source for one question would necessarily be the best source for another.

Example in Action

Scenario: The question is, “What time does the school concert begin tonight?” Source cards include a month-old family calendar, a friend who thinks it starts at 7:00, yesterday’s official school message stating 6:30, and a poster from before the schedule changed. Timmy chooses the friend because he sounds sure. Jane notices the official message is newer and directly from the school. Carlos identifies that the old poster may once have been correct but is no longer the strongest source.

Educator action: The educator asks students to evaluate the source for the specific question rather than label sources as always good or always bad. The class discusses why current, direct information matters here.

What this demonstrates: Students use explicit criteria to compare sources, explain why one source deserves more confidence for a particular question, and revise judgments when source information changes.

Educator Prompts

  • Who or what is the source?
  • How current is it?
  • Does it directly answer our question?
  • What would make us more or less confident in it?

Reflection

Ask students to identify what changed in their thinking during the activity and which piece of information, comparison, clue, or reasoning step caused that change.

Real-World Connection

Connect the activity to everyday situations in which children must use this skill before making a decision, solving a problem, accepting a claim, or explaining what happened.

Adaptations

For younger students, reduce the amount of information and use pictures or oral discussion. For older students, add ambiguity, competing explanations, or information that requires more careful justification.

What Successful Practice Looks Like

Students use explicit criteria to compare sources, explain why one source deserves more confidence for a particular question, and revise judgments when source information changes.

CT-005-E02

Strong Support or Weak Support?

Ages 8–14 · 30–40 minutes.View lesson
Link to this lesson
Skill in Action
Children match claims with supporting information and judge whether the support is strong, weak, irrelevant, or incomplete.
Recommended Ages
8–14
Group Size
10+ children; teams of 3–5.
Preparation Time
15 minutes.
Activity Time
30–40 minutes.
Materials
Claim cards; support cards; Strong / Weak / Irrelevant / Need More Information headers; table space.
Preparation
Prepare ordinary claims and several possible supporting details. Avoid controversial topics; use school, weather, objects, schedules, simple observations, or fictional scenarios.

Instructions

  1. Give each team a Claim Card and a mixed set of Support Cards.
  2. Students place each support card under Strong, Weak, Irrelevant, or Need More Information.
  3. For each placement, require the team to explain how the information does or does not support the claim.
  4. Allow another team to challenge one placement by giving a reason.
  5. Teams may move cards when the challenge reveals a stronger evaluation.
  6. Add one new support card and ask whether confidence in the claim should increase, decrease, or stay the same.
  7. Have teams state what additional information they would want before relying on the claim.
  8. Conclude by distinguishing having some support from having enough good support.

Example in Action

Scenario: The claim says, “The classroom plant needs water.” Cards say the soil feels dry, a student watered it yesterday, two leaves are drooping, the pot is blue, and the plant-care tag says to water when the top soil is dry. Timmy places the blue-pot card under Weak. Jane moves it to Irrelevant because color does not support the watering claim. Carlos combines the dry soil with the care tag as stronger support. Mia says the drooping leaves matter but could have more than one cause.

Educator action: The educator asks why two pieces of related information together may be more useful than one alone and emphasizes that students can change a rating when they give a reason.

What this demonstrates: Students distinguish relevant support from irrelevant detail, compare stronger and weaker support, recognize incomplete information, and explain how evidence changes confidence in a claim.

Educator Prompts

  • Does this actually support the claim?
  • How strongly?
  • Could this detail have another explanation?
  • What information would make you more confident?

Reflection

Ask students to identify what changed in their thinking during the activity and which piece of information, comparison, clue, or reasoning step caused that change.

Real-World Connection

Connect the activity to everyday situations in which children must use this skill before making a decision, solving a problem, accepting a claim, or explaining what happened.

Adaptations

For younger students, reduce the amount of information and use pictures or oral discussion. For older students, add ambiguity, competing explanations, or information that requires more careful justification.

What Successful Practice Looks Like

Students distinguish relevant support from irrelevant detail, compare stronger and weaker support, recognize incomplete information, and explain how evidence changes confidence in a claim.

CT-005-E03

Information Checkpoint

Ages 9–14 · 35–45 minutes.View lesson
Link to this lesson
Skill in Action
Children evaluate practical information before using it in a simulated real-world plan and decide what should be confirmed first.
Recommended Ages
9–14
Group Size
10+ children; teams of 4–6.
Preparation Time
15–20 minutes.
Activity Time
35–45 minutes.
Materials
Planning packet with mixed information; checkpoint cards; pencils; optional highlighters.
Preparation
Create a simple plan such as attending a community event or organizing a class activity. Include current confirmed information, an older item, an unverified statement, and a relevant official instruction.

Instructions

  1. Give each team the planning goal and information packet.
  2. Before making the plan, students mark each item as Ready to Use, Check First, or Not Relevant.
  3. Teams explain the criterion used for each classification.
  4. Students build a preliminary plan using only information they consider sufficiently reliable.
  5. Reveal confirmation cards that resolve two uncertain items.
  6. Teams update the plan and identify anything that still should not be treated as confirmed.
  7. Have teams explain one mistake that could have resulted from using unchecked information.
  8. Finish by creating a short class checklist for evaluating practical information before acting on it.

Example in Action

Scenario: A class plans to attend a Saturday community science fair. The packet includes this year’s official flyer, last year’s parking map, a student’s statement that admission is free, and the organizer’s current notice that tickets are required but cost nothing. Timmy treats “free admission” as meaning no ticket is needed. Jane notices the official notice says a free ticket is still required. Carlos marks the old parking map Check First.

Educator action: The educator asks students to distinguish “free” from “no ticket required” and to identify which pieces are current and direct enough to use without further checking.

What this demonstrates: Students evaluate information before acting, distinguish confirmed from uncertain information, identify outdated or irrelevant material, and update a plan when stronger information becomes available.

Educator Prompts

  • Is this ready to use or should we check it first?
  • What makes this information strong enough for our purpose?
  • Is it current?
  • What could go wrong if we rely on this without checking?

Reflection

Ask students to identify what changed in their thinking during the activity and which piece of information, comparison, clue, or reasoning step caused that change.

Real-World Connection

Connect the activity to everyday situations in which children must use this skill before making a decision, solving a problem, accepting a claim, or explaining what happened.

Adaptations

For younger students, reduce the amount of information and use pictures or oral discussion. For older students, add ambiguity, competing explanations, or information that requires more careful justification.

What Successful Practice Looks Like

Students evaluate information before acting, distinguish confirmed from uncertain information, identify outdated or irrelevant material, and update a plan when stronger information becomes available.

Return to top ↑

Practice in everyday life

For Parents & Families

These activities are designed for natural family use with little or no special equipment.

Who Would Know Best?

Best For: Ages 6+

Where to Try It: During everyday questions about school, stores, events, travel, or family plans

What to Do: When the family needs information, name two or three possible sources and let the child decide which one is most likely to know accurately.

What to Ask: Who is closest to the information? Is it current? Could we check another source?

Why It Helps: Children learn that where information comes from affects how confidently it should be used.

Check Before We Use It

Best For: Ages 7+

Where to Try It: While using schedules, hours, directions, event notices, or online information

What to Do: Before acting on a piece of practical information, have the child check the date, source, and whether it directly answers the family’s question.

What to Ask: How old is this? Who provided it? Does it actually tell us what we need?

Why It Helps: Children practice quick real-world evaluation without treating every piece of information as equally reliable.

How Strong Is That?

Best For: Ages 8+

Where to Try It: During family conversations, stories, advertisements, or everyday claims

What to Do: Choose a harmless claim and ask what information supports it. Rate the support as strong, weak, or not enough yet.

What to Ask: What supports that? Is that enough? What else would we want to know?

Why It Helps: Children learn to connect confidence to the quality of supporting information.

Return to top ↑

Practice Through Games

A future opportunity

Create Your Own

Have another hands-on way for children to practice Evaluating Information? Educators will be able to create a real-world activity using the same format as Tandem Tales lessons and submit it for consideration. Selected activities may become an Official Tandem Tales Critical-Thinking Lesson.

Lesson submissions are not open yet.